Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

was doing a kick boxing class and the student i was paired up with had a strong roundhouse kick, i was holding thai pads for him. i told the student to kick lighter and he did as it was hurting my arms, but instructor came along and edged him to kick harder even when student said yea he cant handle the kick . i could take it for 6 kicks but after that my arms started to really hurt. i evaded one kick as it was too hard and instructor said you need toughen up. 

i think instructor was trying in injure me. my arm is bruised also got feeling instructor doesnt like me as he didnt come along and give me pointers in my technique but he did with other studentss

whats your thoughts.

Posted

It's hard to gauge what the instructor's intentions were and what it means that he didn't come give you pointers as well. It's possible that he's a total jerk, it's also possible that you're taking it personally whereas it's actually just him not being mindful of how his actions might affect your experience. If you feel like he's not looking out for you or is actually intentionally trying to hurt you, take care to protect yourself. 

  • Like 2
Posted
On 5/6/2019 at 8:41 PM, jet67 said:

was doing a kick boxing class and the student i was paired up with had a strong roundhouse kick, i was holding thai pads for him. i told the student to kick lighter and he did as it was hurting my arms, but instructor came along and edged him to kick harder even when student said yea he cant handle the kick . i could take it for 6 kicks but after that my arms started to really hurt. i evaded one kick as it was too hard and instructor said you need toughen up. 

i think instructor was trying in injure me. my arm is bruised also got feeling instructor doesnt like me as he didnt come along and give me pointers in my technique but he did with other studentss

whats your thoughts.

I dont think the instructor was intentionally trying to hurt you. I do think hes out of touch with what it feels like to hold for a heavy kicker or what it was like when he started. Do you need to adapt to the process? Yes, but you also need time to do it and not feel destroyed during the process. Sometimes coaches are more fighter oriented, meaning they orient towards the harder aspects of the sport and training. Those ones tend to forget that a lot of people train in the arts for stress release and fitness. Some of them are really disconnected to the hobbyist. Suggestion: if you go back, pick a partner whos kicks you can handle. Maybe speak to the instructor and make your goals known. If none of that works and you get the same vibe, then I highly suggest finding another spot that caters to your wants and needs. Just my two cents. 

  • Like 3

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Most Recent Topics

  • Latest Comments

    • The Americanization of Thailand's Muay Thai - and with that, its Globalization - (Chatri is afterall an American) has followed the NBA with deleterious results. Rajadamnern specifically tailors its crowd entertainment around the NBA models, attempting to Hype crowd its bored and uninformed tourism fan base, it is what it is. There is not much to do when the fans in the seats aren't really "fans" of the sport. But, much deeper than that, the combo-heavy rule changes which promoted lessor skilled memorized "moves" and abject aggression over defense or spatial control hints at the deeper culture, media laden aspects of "Entertainment" fighting. Even in the NBA, where there is a firm foundation and tradition of basketball skill growth, the media form has distorted the sport into "highlight culture" and advanced stat watching. Again and again you'll see that people like to argue and analyze about the sport on social media more than they actually like to watch the games. It's become a factory for talk and argument. Because its also a multi-billion dollar industry it also drives very high level athleticism, so the narrowed out skill sets being pushed - practiced dribble-moves that bend the traveling boundary, catch and shoot 3s, dunks and flops, all are done with high level of accomplishment, but Thailand's Muay Thai is not so lucky in this wake of Circus Entertainments. Instead, Thailand's incredibly subtle and complex fighting system has been disbanded in favor of low-skill, low-entry fighting styles that can be farmed for clips. Thai fighters themselves are now in gyms learning bite-down combos and clashing, and the entire edifice of Thailand fighting is crumbling before highlight culture and tourist audiences that need to be entertained. The rules have changed, the judging aesthetics have been changed to try and feed this commercial enterprise, all to draw in foreign participation and its dollars. Really, its hard to see this as anything other than part of the deskilling trend of Capitalism as it seeks to produce both spectacle and squeezed profit, turning craft into "labor". Instead of the NBA's 15 billion dollar financial flows feeding skills, instead it is just a Tourist industry hoping to draw more and more foreigners in, as Thais actually lose the elusive aura of skills and grace that made Thailand a destination for historical fight glory. The historical legacy and capacity to fight that is lost is not found in unique "moves" or tricks for farang taught in gyms, and it certainly isn't found in the import of "combos" taught by new style pad men and pad holding. The forces that bring these new distillations out are largely economic and media defined, stripping away the very Form of Life that made Thailand's Muay Thai was it was. Oddly enough, Thai fighters themselves have become ostensibly tourists in their own country, learning how to participate in the Circus culture designed for the foreigner's entertainment, or more usually, laborers in the Tourist Industry. Because the economics are so different from the NBA - and the value of its changes vs skills developed can be argued about separately - its at great variance if one mimics the NBA with an entirely different (tourism driven) economic base. Notice as well, its not just a matter of "everything having to grow" or some sort of fatalism of Capitalism and technological technique-farming - there is a world-wide sport that has been globalized without being fetishized for highlight culture...football/soccer, a trillion dollar industry, a prime example.
    • -No prescription required
  • The Latest From Open Topics Forum

  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      1.4k
    • Total Posts
      11.7k
×
×
  • Create New...