Jump to content

"Armed Rural Folk: Elements of Pre-colonial Warfare in the Artistic Representations and Written Accounts of the Pacification Campaign (1886–1889) in Burma" Michael W. Charney


Recommended Posts

I'm going to post a copy of Michael Charney's excellent article here as it is hard to find, and is an important piece in the history of Thailand's Muay Thai, in so far as it can be conceived in the context of mainland Southeast Asian warfare. It drives the the heart of the difficulty we have of even picturing the preponderance of warfare there may have been, as our record is powerfully overbalanced by Kingdom chronicle and its perspective. In fact, the vast majority of organized conflict likely was rural and between settlements and smaller polities. It's important to see this, as it was likely martial pressure that was most operative in developing a mode of fighting. (My own hypothesis has been that Muay Thai (Boran), likely developed less out of battle and conflict itself, and more out of a parallel line of (betting) ring fighting rites and custom. This text is found in "WARRING SOCIETIES OF PRECOLONIAL
SOUTHEAST ASIA".RuralWarfareinBurma04.thumb.PNG.53632228a6a5b65b4df7b72b298f9eb2.PNGRuralWarfareinBurma05.thumb.PNG.b56e135f716e3d395ac48ca2a76e3570.PNGRuralWarfareinBurma06.thumb.PNG.17471b2b3817fb2da5a72baee6fe1338.PNGRuralWarfareinBurma07.thumb.PNG.a72cc3387a93c4b459445adcb2238563.PNGRuralWarfareinBurma08.thumb.PNG.e839311d58601a5cb3c94d860f6fbb42.PNGRuralWarfareinBurma09.thumb.PNG.56a4e788bf74be62a50240692f8de8ea.PNGRuralWarfareinBurma9.thumb.PNG.adca704051c19c23bd0e2fa92e046e5d.PNGRuralWarfareinBurma10.thumb.PNG.fff5f7926b5da21088df127de4af3cb8.PNGRuralWarfareinBurma11.thumb.PNG.5e14ec9f864df759a2bb1bb96c20f3fd.PNGRuralWarfareinBurma12.thumb.PNG.5927b53dd165978e91614b740143a71d.PNGRuralWarfareinBurma13.thumb.PNG.7016ba24d1260b80362fe5adc2d591b7.PNGRuralWarfareinBurma14.thumb.PNG.2b1e6f5f7f812e023cba8190751f6538.PNGRuralWarfareinBurma15.thumb.PNG.7801904646d6e3d83fd6034e3a166115.PNGRuralWarfareinBurma16.thumb.PNG.627ac5e022782ec335b0b1744db6fc58.PNGRuralWarfareinBurma17.thumb.PNG.4c94405d9b68509f14b79b113b288ec1.PNGRuralWarfareinBurma18.thumb.PNG.6b02b9ce208f5cb24a7dc25ab1be0821.PNGRuralWarfareinBurma19.thumb.PNG.740c186349daa81ab0b9267b9ce346e0.PNGRuralWarfareinBurma20.thumb.PNG.f963a98a806486a431df04a757f89ccf.PNGRuralWarfareinBurma21.thumb.PNG.39b9f9c4ede9ff0d2a64a57868eb7137.PNGRuralWarfareinBurma22.thumb.PNG.9bc79d69740b022b948c4e1517d47720.PNGRuralWarfareinBurma23.thumb.PNG.6e239e4a5ebb757b9a3ac36a9ac41d15.PNGRuralWarfareinBurma24.thumb.PNG.3d4652395da2d88d63b222691758b172.PNGRuralWarfareinBurma25.thumb.PNG.0087cc758574a8626270f71fdf2570e1.PNGRuralWarfareinBurma26.thumb.PNG.a7649477933bb39d7e7afdd4fa0fb9bd.PNGRuralWarfareinBurma27.thumb.PNG.0019b2e17e449dd34357ce456f3acdbc.PNGRuralWarfareinBurma28.thumb.PNG.d2c79f1f5040e55b7836c95c66e86b6c.PNGRuralWarfareinBurma29.thumb.PNG.7ff4f2caadcca036a3bc2e4765951786.PNGRuralWarfareinBurma30.thumb.PNG.1d257561a1114bd093ed7c749ed28c68.PNG

 

This article is posted in reference to the much wider thesis of Thailand's defensive fighting style here:

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Most Recent Topics

  • Latest Comments

    • I am soon to be 17 and I’ve been training Muay Thai for nearly 3 years now. I also happen to be doing quite well in school and plan to go to uni. However, that all changed when I went to Thailand last summer to train for a few weeks and fight. One of the trainers, with whom I have developed a close connection, told me not to go back home and stay in Thailand in order build a career. “You stay, become superstar” to quote him, as he pointed at the portraits of their best fighters hung on the gym’s wall. After realizing he wasn’t joking, I told him I couldn’t stay and had to finish my last year of high school (which is what I am currently doing) but promised him I’d come back the following year once I was done with school. Ever since, both these words and my love for Muay Thai resonate in me, and I can’t get the idea of becoming a professional fighter out of my head. On one hand, I’m afraid I’m being lied to, since me committing to being a fighter obviously means he gets more pay to be my coach. But on the other hand, it is quite a reputable and trustworthy gym, and this trainer in particular is an incredible coach and pad holders since he is currently training multiple rws fighters including one who currently holds an rws belt. And for a little more context, I don’t think this invitation to become a pro came out of nowhere, because during those few weeks I trained extremely hard and stayed consistent, which I guess is what impressed him and motivated him to say those words. Additionally, I was already thinking about the possibility of going pro before the trip because of my love for Muay Thai and because a female boxing champion who has close ties to my local gym told me I had potential and a fighter’s mindset. Therefore, I have to pick between two great opportunities, one being college and a stable future, and the other being a Muay Thai career supported by a great gym and coach. So far, I plan to do a gap year to give myself more time to make a decision and to begin my training in order to give myself an idea of how hard life as a pro is. This is a big decision which I definitely need help with, so some advice would be greatly appreciated.
    • When I've come out to Thailand to train (and holiday!), I've always trained just once a week for the first one. It takes a while for the body to adjust, especially with the heat and/ or humidity, and gives me a chance to recover and explore. After that, it depends on how I feel/ what my goals are. Sometimes I've switched to twice a day, other times I haven't. If you're coming out to fight, you might want to. If it's just to train, improve and enjoy your stay, sometimes twice a day is a slog. Your decision... Chok dee.
  • The Latest From Open Topics Forum

  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      1.4k
    • Total Posts
      11.6k
×
×
  • Create New...